Debian buries it’s head in the sand, sticks it arse in the air and Digg users ram it home!
I just read a a post on Digg which just gets right up my nose! It’s entitle “Debian Forced to Stop using name “Firefox” which perfectly crafted to begin a flame war.
Not only that, a lot of people promote sites like Digg.com because they demonstrate the “wisdom of the crowd”, this however only displays that some members of crowd are capable of idiotic knee jerk reactions without even reading through the referenced material.
Way to go Diggers!
Here’s the original digg quote, the actual blog post it points to and here’s the discussion that started it all:
The Mozilla Foundation has asked Debian Linux to either use both the ‘Firefox’ name and the Artwork or get rid of both. Because the Artwork has non-free Copyright License, it seems Debian (and most likely, many other Linux Distros) has no choice but to change the name of the application to something else. IceWeasel is the number one choice so far!
Okay, first let me give my opinion on the actual point of the article, as it’s rather simple: Mozilla Corp are 100% right in defending their trademark. It’s that simple. My understanding of US law with regards to this requires them to enforce their trademark or lose it.
Mozilla have provided Debian with a simple means to use the Firefox browser without any trademarked branding, so they can do with it as they will. Debian wants to have their cake and eat it. They want to use the trademarked name, but not the logo.
Well lads, you can’t have one without the other. So pucker up and change, just like you expect everyone else to if they wanted to release their own Debian distro and still call it Debian!
Now I complained about the Digg crowd being knee jerk and idiotic but I wasn’t referring to all of them. There were plenty of clear voices of reason among the fanboy idiots but it was comments like these that made me think “Who the hell are these morons?”:
- Didn’t Firefox gain the browser market they have now through grass roots marketing? It was thousands of bloggers and webmasters plastering the “Get Firefox” buttons on their sites, with the Firefox logo. Now they want to give the middle finger to that same group of people?
Is there any sanity left in the software world? - Geez… Renaming Firefox? Sounds like that’s just going to cause more confusing in the already splintered world of Linux.
So Mozilla *asked* them not to use the name Firefox. Does that mean Debian *has* to? Can they just snub their nose at Mozilla and use the name anyway, sans the logo? - I’ve never heard of Debian Linux. I’ve heard of Debian GNU/Linux. . .
On to subject, that’s fucked of the Moz devs to do. Debian is their friend. - Until the logo is made free Firefox cannot be considered FOSS as the logo is an integral part of the identity of the software.
- fuck Mozilla.
- … and people wonder why Linux doesn’t have more desktop share. Great time to be idealistic, Firefox peeps!
- Debian is not and never has been a desktop distribution.
There were others as well, but I’m too lazy to copy and paste them. Also I’m not even going to explain why all of these comments are lame and made by people who couldn’t be bothered to spend a little time reading about something before jumping to an uninformed conclusion. And trust me, I’m very good at being that kind of lazy uninformed person, so I know what I’m talking about here!
The worst thing is that it’s not just this particular post in question. I’m seeing more and more of this on other social/news sites and it really dilutes the quality and value of those services for me. I’m sure it does for other you to!
I’m sure it also degrades the value of the service for the guys who make those daft comments without thinking, unless of course, that’s the kind of thing they like, flamewars etc…
