Todd Cochrane of Geek News Central replied to my post “Deathmatch: Kirkpartick VS Cochrane“.
It went a little something like this (I encourage you to read the actual post ) :
No name blogger blah Online Deathmatch Blah Blah.. can’t see past the end of my nose for the fear or data mining.. blah blah blah…
SplashCast.(EVIL) WAAAH!!.. bah blah blah… FeedBurner.. Blah!stance is not new… blah blah.. .. blah…
Spread some more fear.. blah blah blah…
Okay, that’s not really what Todd wrote but it’s what I go out of it.
I’m sorry Todd but I think that you’re way off base with your post.
I never said you and Marshall should have an online deathmatch but instead an MTV Celebrity Deathmatch. You know, the claymation show on MTV? I though it would be a fun thing to watch!
Anyway, I guess “a certain blogger” is just nitpicking.
The point of my post was that there is no apparent love lost between you and Marshall and your comments yesterday were simply far below what I’ve come to expect of you as a blogger and podcaster.
Marshall’s comment was simple yet very effective. Simply pointing out the existence of the MyBlogLog widget on your site showed and obvious bias in your thinking with regards to large companies collecting data on users.
There was no need for Marshall to discuss the rest of the article.
Yahoo is no different to Google in wanting to gather as much information on users and their habits as possible.
Google may be the top dog now, but it was not always so and it may not remain so.
Anyway, I digress. This post is not about my thinking on the issue of Google buying FeedBurner and collecting user data. That’s a whole other post.
The point here is that Marshall pointed out the MBL widget and your replying comment was, well, childish to be honest.
It was almost like something I would have expected in an exchange between 2 children on a playground.
There was no need to bring up the SplashCast incident in relation to the discussion. Simply no need.
It as if you were trying to rub Marshall’s nose in it, like a dog who has misbehaved or simply saying “My daddies bigger than your daddy”.
Some people might even call it primitive chest beating.
That’s the issue.
That was the point I was writing about.
Not the past or the future. Not what may or may not happen. Not what your stance on various issues was before.
It’s about a blogger and podcaster that I like and respect being childish and petty with his comments.
We all do it from time to time. I’m no angel! I’m sure I’ve done it loads of times and I’m sure my readers will suitably chastise me if I do it again.
You’ve got to see the beyond the individual trees and look at the whole forest.
The SplashCast thing is over and done with. There is no need to keep rubbing salt in old wounds.
Yes, you may think Google buying FeedBurner is bad for privacy. Some folks don’t.
People will decide if this is good or bad for them and make their choices accordingly.
We just don’t need respected bloggers being petty and childish while discussing it.
That does not make for a good conversation.
Tags:
bloggers,
blogging,
commenting,
Deathmatch,
Feedburner,
Google,
Internet,
Marshall-Kirkpatrick,
MTV,
Privacy,
response,
splashcast,
Todd-Cochrane